Wednesday, July 8, 2015

Deflategate math

There are a number laws relating to gasses that show a proportional relationship. One of these is Charles’ Law. Jacques Charles was the uncommon combination scientist/balloonist. He co-developed and rode in the first hydrogen balloon in 1783. Manned balloon flight was it its golden age and Charles played an important part.

Charles’ Law states that with pressure remaining constant, the volume of a gas are in direct variation. The experts say that tire pressure should be measured before driving as the act of driving will cause the air in the tire to heat up and thus expand.

You might be aware that a basketball left in the cold doesn’t bounce very well. That is because the decreased temperature means a reduced volume of air in the ball. If it is brought inside or run under hot water it will regain its bounciness.

A similar law, Gay-Lussac’s Law, states a directly proportional relationship between temperature (measure in degrees Kelvin) and pressure.

Some examples:
- A basketball is left outside at 8 degrees Celsius. Its volume was 444 cubic inches. Brought inside, it warmed up to 32 degrees. What is its volume now?

First of all, we need to be in Kelvins, so K = C+273, means the ball’s temperature went from 281 to 305 degrees Kelvin. Now setting up our proportion we see,

                                             444 : 281 = x : 305   →     x = 483 cubic inches


- NFL Rule 2.1 states that “The ball shall be made up of an inflated (12 1/2 to 13 1/2 pounds) urethane bladder…”. It is claimed that the Patriots football team has under-inflated the ball to try to gain an advantage. A league report claims that at least one of the balls was inflated to only 10.5 pounds per square inch. Suppose the Patriots then claim that according to Gay-Lussac’s Law the football would naturally lose pressure as it was brought from the warmth of the locker room to the field. If the locker room was 75° F (297.04° K) and the field temperature was 40° F (277.5944° K), might the Patriot’s claim that the football was actually within the guidelines?  

Our proportion comparing pressure and temperature could be written as:

                                            10.5 :  277.59 = x : 297.04 

We get an answer of 11.2 psi, which is still under the 12.5 minimum.